Stila eyeshadow in Kitten, a top seller at Sephora, makes for pretty eyelids, and helps you look like you're not bored or sleepy, which you might be right now. (It's heading past eleven o'clock.) If you apply it lightly across the lid, the shimmer is very subtle. Don't be afraid to reach beyond the eyelid and brush it right below your eyebrow too.
Buy it: Kitten Eyeshadow by Stila ($16), Sephora.